Is Trump's Attraction to Russia About Shaping the U.S. Version of Putin's 21st-Century, Postmodern, Authoritarian, Kleptocratic Regime?

[chan] newswire
Jul 4 20:17

Steven Rosenfeld, AlterNet Mon, 03 Jul 2017 15:39:00 -0700 [Reuse options] Click here for reuse options! <> Yale historian Timothy Snyder asserts that Trump's ties to Russia are far deeper and more dangerous than campaign collusion. The links between President Trump and Russia will prove to be deeper and darker than many Americans now believe. This is according to Timothy Snyder, a noted historian of the 20th century’s tyrannical regimes in Eastern Europe, who said the U.S. is now moving down a cultural and political path that has much in common with Russia under Vladimir Putin’s authoritarian and oligarchic rule. “Where I am coming from is, it can happen. It happens to people like us. And it’s happening now,” he said, speaking in mid-June at the International Festival of Arts and Ideas at Yale University where he is a history professor. “It’s happening now. We’re not in some strange dream. We’re not in some American exceptionalist moment. We’re in a moment where this is happening throughout the West.” Snyder is author of the late-2016 pamphlet /On Tyranny: Twenty Lessons From The Twentieth Century/ <>, which warned what a Trump presidency could bring and noted how widespread civic resistance could stop American authoritarianism. In his speech, he described how Trump was relying on Putin’s Russia as a model for where he was taking America. Some of this is already known, such as Trump's campaign links to Russians and Americans working for Russian political allies and oligarchs. And some is not widely known, such as how Russia’s major way of interfering in the election was not hacking into voting machines or even stealing Democratic Party emails, but rather funneling propagandistic pro-Trump messaging via Facebook to sway voters in swing states. Overall, Snyder's message is that the United States is not unique—neither in the world today nor against the backdrop of history—in being pushed in more authoritarian directions. If anything, Trump is exploiting the same tactics Putin and state-run media in Russia use, but with the American addiction to 24/7 media and smartphones and other devices, we’re making it easier for an emerging authoritarian like Trump to consolidate his power. “What’s happening to us in the United States of America in 2016, 2017, it isn’t just happening here,” he said. “In the first decade of the century, history was going from the west to the east. That hasn’t been true for some time... For the past several years, history has been coming from the east to the west… The cyber war, fake news, those things are old news in some places…. They are only new here. The fact we’re shocked by them is because we’re provincial. We’re not paying attention.” “The question I want to ask here is, what have we gotten us into?” Snyder says, launching into the facts that have become known in the nearly six months since Trump and the GOP have taken office. “We are going to learn all kinds of things. Not everyone agrees with me… but I think we are going to find out that the connections between the Trump campaign and various Russian actors were deeper, darker and more spectacular than we could have imagined. I am pretty sure that’s how it’s going to turn out. But even if I am wrong, the Russia connection is very important because Russia is a model of how you run a 21st-century, postmodern, authoritarian, kleptocratic, unequal regime. And it is a positive model for the president of the United States… It’s also a model of how you use terrorism, the threat of terror and the reality of terrorism, to stabilize inequality over the long term; a positive model, as the president himself has said, for how you use the politics of terror.” Snyder said Russia is important not merely because it meddled deeply in the 2016 election—just as it has meddled in recent elections across Europe—but “because Russia is a possible future. That is the way that we are heading.” Turning back to the 2016 election, he said Russia’s biggest impact wasn’t just stealing email from the Democratic National Committee and Hillary Clinton campaign. Trump urging the Russians to keep finding and releasing emails was an overlooked telltale sign. “Now we know that there was much more of it and it was much more profoundly important than was understood,” he said, “that the main element of the Russian intervention in the election had to do with gathering political data about tens of millions of Americans, and then using Facebook and other platforms to target fake news to people who were regarded as susceptible, especially in the last weeks before the election, which probably determined the outcome in critical states that were targeted, which probably determined the outcome of the election as a whole. This isn’t to say that there aren’t other reasons, and in my view, good reasons, why people could vote for Mr. Trump. It isn’t to say that Hillary Clinton ran a wonderful campaign either. It’s just to say that in a very close election, that probably made the difference.” Snyder emphasized he was not alone in this conclusion. “This isn’t just me saying this,” he said. “These are the conclusion of America’s intelligence agencies as well as, although you have to read between the lines a little bit, the conclusion of Facebook itself. Facebook has acknowledged it was used in this way.” *Trump's Russian Dossier* Then Snyder went through the Trump campaign’s senior staff who had personal connections to Russian allies, oligarchs and Putin. He started with Paul Manafort, who didn’t take a salary, but managed Trump’s campaign through the Republican National Convention. “Paul Manafort was not paid by the Trump campaign. On the other hand, he was on a million-dollar-a-year contract for several years for an oligarch close to Mr. Putin to soften up American democracy for Russian influence. That could be a coincidence. You could say that job ended before the campaign. That’s true because Mr. Manafort took up another job [after the convention], which was to be the main strategist for the Ukrainian president, Viktor Yanukovych, who Mr. Manafort helped back to power." There’s plenty more, he said. “Trump’s first foreign policy speech was written by someone who was on the payroll of a Russian gas company… We knew that Mr. Flynn, his national security adviser, was paid $45,000 by a Russian propaganda outlet upon which he had appeared multiple times… Now we have a secretary of state who was given the Order of Friendship by Vladimir Putin, which might be a curiosity in a different context—but is not a curiosity at all. We have an attorney general, the highest law enforcement official in the land, who perjured himself in his own confirmation hearings under oath on precisely the question of his contacts with Russia. We have a senior adviser in the White House who happens to be the son-in-law of the president, Mr. Kushner, who also lied in order to get security clearance—which, if you were a normal person would be a problem, right? If Mr. Sessions were a normal lawyer, he could be disbarred, right? If we had a rule of law state, Mr. Kushner could not get security clearance because he left out his contacts with Russian officials.” Snyder continued, saying Trump’s firing of FBI director James Comey—who was heading the investigation into his campaign ties to Russia—and his threats to fire Robert Mueller, who took over that investigation, were tantamount to confessions. “I wish I was making this stuff up,” he said. “And Mr. Trump’s personal lawyer is the personal lawyer of the main Russian oligarch. A man named Oleg Deripaska, who is very close to Mr. Putin, and he was also very close to Mr. Manafort. Now it could possibly all be a coincidence, but we could ask the question a different way: couldn’t the president have a lawyer who is not also the lawyer for the other side? If the president is denying his connections to Russia, could he not find a lawyer who is also not representing the Russians? Right? There are a lot of lawyers and they are not all representing Russian oligarchs.” Snyder’s inventory of Trump’s ties to people doing business in Russia and to wealthy or powerful Russians was in the service of a larger point. He believes that the same kind of authoritarian rule that now exists in Russia is where Trump is taking the country. The story that Americans tell themselves about being exceptions to history—all the shining city on a hill stuff—is clouding our ability to see that this is exactly what’s happening, he said. The reason we look at history, he added, is not just to familiarize ourselves with what’s possible, but to recognize dangerous trends and try to prevent them. What’s currently working against that is the country is getting used to Trump’s antics, his lies and deceptions, and his policies that are going to transfer more wealth from the man to the few. “I’m trying to get us out of this trap where we get bombarded with bad news, and we empathize with our friends, but we’re not sure what to do and then the next day is the same. And you get enough days like that, and then everything normalizes and then it’s too late, and then you’re done,” he said. “And then you have an authoritarian regime and then your children don’t know what freedom is.” *What Can Be Done?* Snyder recounted the biggest lessons from his book on resisting tyranny. “The first is, don’t obey in advance,” he said. “When we imagine a Hitler or a Stalin, we imagine a fully formed supervillain coming onstage. That’s not how it happens. What’s necessary is consent. Consent can be not doing anything, looking away, saying that it’s normal, saying that it can’t happen here, saying that the institutions are going to save us, and doing nothing—that’s consent. That’s the kind of consent that authoritarian regimes need. They need some act of participation, but mostly they need that kind of consent.” “If authoritarian regime changes are to be resisted, they have to be resisted in the first six to 18 months,” he continued. “If they are not, then you lose the chance to do anything. The devastating psychological-political connection is when you say, ‘It can’t happen here,’ or, ‘Well, I’ll do something tomorrow,’ or ‘Well, my friends aren’t doing anything yet,’ and then the time passes. The tragedy is then that you have lost time that you cannot get back.” His second lesson is to support institutions—even if that means pressuring a Congress poised to do bad things (like taking healthcare away from tens of millions), because the American form of government needs to be pushed into exercising checks and balances. Similarly, professionals need to stand up for and assert professional standards as a counterpoint to unethical and unprofessional activities at the top of the government. “If lawyers and doctors and civil servants just hold steady, just hold onto some notion of what’s normal and good, then that can slow things down a lot,” he said. Third is not allowing oneself to be forced into hiding—as is already happening with many people in communities of color where family members don’t have legal visas. He said people need to organize in public and not buy into the myth of lone heroic actors. “In the American idea of freedom, it’s always that lone person against the overwhelming power of the government. And I am here to tell you in that situation in real life, the lone person always gets completely hammered. Or the lone person never actually makes that stand because when you’re a lone person you don’t make stands,” he said. Finally, he said that the truth—and fighting for fact-based thresholds for political debate and decisions—matters greatly. The descent into media ghettos and social media silos of like-minded people with shared but erroneous beliefs is what allows authoritarians to take power, he said, and that is another similarity between the U.S. and Russia under Putin. Modern authoritarians “go after the truth,” he said. “And they go after it in a three-part scheme. You fill the public space with lies and contradictions; you don’t acknowledge they’re lies and contradictions. Step two is you say it’s the journalists who lie. Step three is, if you win, everybody says, ‘Well, maybe’s he’s right. What is truth? Who knows? You have your story, I have my story. I’m just going to watch Netflix.'" “'I’m just going to watch Netflix' is what Putin has tattooed on his thigh,” he continued. “I’m just going to watch Netflix is basically how Russian-style authoritarianism works. People spending huge amounts of time in front of the screen, not believing that any of it is true, but—this is modern nationalism—preferring their own country’s untruth to the untruth of other countries, right?" “That’s what it comes down to in the end. When you achieve this state of doubt, you end up creating this weird kind of nationalism—which if you haven’t noticed in the U.S. you are not getting out enough. A weird kind of nationalism where people say, ‘Well, it’s not true. The press is not true. The journalists, the media, the media.’ And yet you prefer your own untruths. That’s what modern right-wing authoritarianism looks like and that’s where we’re moving.” Snyder said such chaotic clashes between fake news and the truth have been persistent features of authoritarian regimes. Under Germany, there was the fantasy of the National Socialists representing "the people,” which wasn’t the same as all people. Communists had different fantasies about utopian futures that were cited to justify a catalog of power-grabbing abuses and maltreatment of citizenry. What worries him the most about Trump’s Russian connections are not his associates’ personal ties, per se, but how American society, culture and its political institutions are becoming Russia-like. “Democracy is failing in many parts of the world today,” Snyder said, in closing. “A nationalist will say it can’t happen here, which is the first step toward disaster. A patriot says that it could happen here, but that we will stop it.” [Reuse options]Click here for reuse options! <> Related Stories * President Donald Trump Is Telling Lies at an Astonishing and Historical Rate <> * What Is Insanity in the Age of Trump? <> * Melania Trump Drops Fake Cyber Bullying Campaign She Only Pretended to Care About <> Attachments: alternet.png 0 bytes

[chan] newswire

Subject Last Count
The Life, Death, and Legacy of iPhone Jailbreaking - Motherboard Jul 4 21:53 2
Juha Saarinen: Stop the cyber war now - New Zealand Herald Jul 4 21:53 1
Pope: Hunger caused by 'indifference of many, selfishness of a few' - Catholic News Service Jul 4 21:53 1
Cyberattack On Israeli Hospitals Led By 'Palestinian' Hacker - Jul 4 21:53 1
U.S. Cyber Warrior Begins NATO Job as Trump Pressures Alliance ... - Bloomberg Jul 4 21:53 1
Derry republican Tony Taylor to sue Secretary of State for wrongful arrest and false imprisonment - Derry Now Jul 4 21:53 1
The Petrov Affair: Russian spy couple who defected to Australia during Cold War - Brisbane Times Jul 4 21:53 1
Vatican note on Reformed Churches' signing of Justification ... - Vatican Radio Jul 4 21:53 1
Foisting Blame for Cyber-Hacking on Russia - Jul 4 21:53 2
Paul Goble: 8 reasons why Russian Communism and Russian Orthodoxy are so interchangeable - Kyiv Post Jul 4 21:53 1
Five Eyes Unlimited: What A Global Anti-Encryption Regime Could ... - EFF Jul 4 21:53 1
CIA has been hacking into Wi-Fi routers for years, leaked documents show - ZDNet Jul 4 21:53 1
HTTPS Certificate Revocation is broken, and it’s time for some new tools Jul 4 21:53 1
Is the 'deep state' paranoia of Texas Republicans a sign of times to come? - Daily Kos Jul 4 21:53 1
United Nations News Centre - On anniversary of Somalia's ... - UN News Centre Jul 4 21:53 1
Lawmakers must step up to protect digital privacy - Herald-Whig - - Herald-Whig Jul 4 21:53 1
How AMC's 'Preacher' Hopes to Bring a "Degree of Affection" for Hitler - Hollywood Reporter Jul 4 21:53 1
New Orleans Man Called White Nationalist for Supporting Confederate Monuments - The New American Jul 4 21:53 1
Yes, There Is A Civil War Looming, And The Alt-Right Is Pushing It - HuffPost Jul 4 21:05 1
News Brief: Trump CNN Tweet Is Criticized, Latest Vatican Shake-Up - NPR Jul 4 21:05 1
Lucknow slum children impress at Model United Nations - Hindustan Times Jul 4 21:05 1
No contract, no worries for unemployed cricketers - The Australian Jul 4 21:04 1
Google's Elite Project Zero Hackers Teach Business a Lesson - Fortune Jul 4 21:04 1
Why We HAVE To Start Talking About Child Sex Trafficking - Collective Evolution Jul 4 21:04 1
Officials warn 'hacktavists' could target 2019 election? - BBC News Jul 4 21:03 1
Hacker Fears? US Tech Companies Still Want To Work With Sanctioned Russian Spy Agencies - Forbes Jul 4 21:02 2
Major League Baseball has a racism problem - SB Nation Jul 4 21:02 1
NASA Will Soon Confirm Intelligent Alien Life Existence, Hacker ... - MobiPicker Jul 4 21:01 2
No, Brad Pitt Did Not Confirm Hollywood Is a Child Sex Ring - VICE Jul 4 21:01 1
Great Zionism Survey reveals: 75% of Sephardi Jews in Israel suffered from prejudice - JerusalemOnline Jul 4 21:01 1
Embattled SA attorney faces sex trafficking charges - KSAT San Antonio Jul 4 21:01 1
Petya: Is it ransomware or cyberwarfare? - CSO Online Jul 4 21:01 1
Some Erie County OCY cases part of statewide data breach - Jul 4 21:00 1
Aussie mobile phone use rises to 88pc but privacy fears linger - The Australian Jul 4 21:00 1
Whales, Mail Rail, And A Secret Society: July's Best Exhibitions - Londonist Jul 4 21:00 1
Putin admits he once ran an international spy network | New York Post - New York Post Jul 4 20:59 1
In its final season, 'Turn: Washington's Spies' set pieces go to auction - Jul 4 20:59 1
New Documents Reveal CIA Motives, Tactics in 1953 Iranian Coup - teleSUR English Jul 4 20:59 1
All 17 Intelligence Agencies Did Not Say Russia Hacked Election, New Update Reveals - Jul 4 20:57 1
In its final season, 'Turn: Washington's Spies' set pieces go to auction - Roanoke Times Jul 4 20:57 1
Security Pros, Librarians Holding Digital Privacy Clinics Across US - Jul 4 20:57 1
Shadow Brokers Group Leaks Stolen National Security Agency Hacking Tools - NPR Jul 4 20:55 2
No, NASA is not hiding kidnapped children on Mars - Washington Post Jul 4 20:55 1
Vladimir Putin: inside the Russian leader's inner sanctum - The Australian Jul 4 20:54 1
PayPal Phishing Site Asks Victims to Submit a Selfie Holding Their ID Card - BleepingComputer Jul 4 20:54 1
Trump's America Isn't Any More Independent Than Obama's - Fortune Jul 4 20:50 1
The Hacker Hunters Chasing Russian Shadows - The Moscow Times Jul 4 20:50 2
The Civil Rights Act was a victory against racism. But racists also won. - Washington Post Jul 4 20:50 1
"Nationalist" accused of plot to attack French leader, minorities - CBS News Jul 4 20:49 1
Catholic and Reformed Churches mark ecumenical "milestone" - Vatican Radio Jul 4 20:47 1
A privacy group is suing Trump's election-integrity panel for trying to collect voter data - Business Insider Jul 4 20:46 2
Video: 2018 guard David Duke spring highlights - Inside the Hall Jul 4 20:46 1
Alt-Right in Fat Elvis Mode: 100 or so Nazis gather for “Freedom of ... - Baltimore City Paper (blog) Jul 4 20:44 1
The Age of Detesting Trump - London Review of Books (subscription) Jul 4 20:44 1
Microsoft: Latest security fixes thwart NSA hacking tools - ZDNet Jul 4 20:44 1
VA whistleblower doc faces ax unless Trump steps in - Fox News Jul 4 20:42 1
Bringing children home: A CMU spinoff goes after sex traffickers - Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Jul 4 20:41 1
Report: Status quo on conversions to Judaism in Israel to remain ... - Cleveland Jewish News Jul 4 20:41 1
Vatican hospital offers to take in baby Charlie Gard - CNN Jul 4 20:41 1
Risk — a searching profile of Julian Assange - Financial Times Jul 4 20:41 1
What Fashion Doesn't Get About Black Lives Matter - Refinery29 Jul 4 20:41 1
California internet privacy bill deserves quick OK - The San Diego Union-Tribune Jul 4 20:40 1
Industroyer or Crash Override: This Russian cyber weapon can take ... - Techworm Jul 4 20:40 1
Why more than a million Russians have lined up to see a piece of ... - Washington Post Jul 4 20:34 1
Watch the Drones: Can Black Folks Benefit From the New World Order? - The Root Jul 4 20:34 1
The girl who slapped Goebbels' naughty son.. before his father murdered him: Nurse reveals last, desperate days she ... - Daily Mail Jul 4 20:33 1
FBI Says Hackers Managed to Extort $28 Million in Cryptocurrencies - The Merkle Jul 4 20:33 2
By Facebook&#39;s Logic, Who Is Protected From Hate ... - Wired - WIRED Jul 4 20:33 1
GDPR: who needs to hire a data protection officer? - Naked Security Jul 4 20:32 1
Cowboys Casino's data targeted again by anonymous hackers ... - Casinopedia Jul 4 20:32 1
Mr. Sillypants Goes to Washington Jul 4 20:32 1
Leaked Manual Reveals How CIA Can Track Windows Users by Gauging Wi-Fi Signal - Gizmodo Jul 4 20:32 1
Hacks Raise Fear Over N.S.A.'s Hold on Cyberweapons - The New ... - New York Times Jul 4 20:31 1
Petya Weren't Expecting This: Ransomware Takes Systems Hostage Across the Globe - Security Intelligence (blog) Jul 4 20:30 1
Stand up to everyday racism and hate crimes, Jeremy Corbyn urges ... - The Guardian Jul 4 20:29 1
The MSN’s Eliot Ness Jul 4 20:28 1
Russia Hacked Election Systems In 39 US States, Obama Had To Use The “Red Phone” Warning - Fossbytes Jul 4 20:28 1
Hacker, Hack Thyself Jul 4 20:27 1
The alt-right is tearing itself apart. What remains after will be the future of far-right politics. - Mic Jul 4 20:26 1
Were the Founding Fathers White Supremacists? Liberals Seem To ... - NewsBusters (press release) (blog) Jul 4 20:25 1
So. A cross-Europe cyberwar simulation. Of ransomware • The ... - The Register Jul 4 20:24 1
Russian Orthodox Church thinks kids should have to learn Church ... - The Calvert Journal Jul 4 20:23 1
Russian TV channel offers gay people one way plane ticket out of ... - The Independent Jul 4 20:23 1
Russia was behind global cyber attack, Ukraine says - The Independent Jul 4 20:23 1
Her artwork was based on videos of her own children. Now she's ... - Washington Post Jul 4 20:23 1
New reports raise some big questions about Michael Flynn and Russian hackers - Vox Jul 4 20:23 1
The cyber attack that knocked out Ukraine this morning is now going global - Quartz Jul 4 20:22 1
Government plays a dangerous game with mass surveillance - The Hill (blog) Jul 4 20:21 1
Councilors,Martins Sound Off on Boston Globe 'Secret Society' Story ... - Everett Independent Jul 4 20:21 1
It's time for the NSA to speak up about its stolen cyber weapons - Salon Jul 4 20:21 1
Powerful new 'Stuxnet II' digital weapon can crash electricity grids and cripple economies, tech experts warn - The Sun Jul 4 20:20 1
Racist thug who ripped niqab from woman's face while yelling 'you f***ing stupid Muslim' swears outside court as he ... - The Sun Jul 4 20:20 1
IBM Named a Leader in Inaugural Gartner Magic Quadrant for Access Management, Worldwide - Security Intelligence (blog) Jul 4 20:19 1
Legalize It - Hacked Jul 4 20:19 1
Hacker "Incursio" Gets Two Years in Prison for Hacking CIA, DHS, DOJ, and FBI - BleepingComputer Jul 4 20:18 1
The Wahhabist Game of Thrones Jul 4 20:18 1
Is Trump's Attraction to Russia About Shaping the U.S. Version of Putin's 21st-Century, Postmodern, Authoritarian, Kleptocratic Regime? Jul 4 20:17 1
Beacon technology opens new doors to personalized marketing - Daily Sabah Jul 4 20:14 2
Abortion remark came from hacker, candidate says - Arizona Capitol Times Jul 4 20:14 1