Flat Earth Society – Introductory Post

[chan] space
Nov 16 09:27

Like my series on the Apollo Moon Hoax, the idea of a “Flat Earth” will be a topic that I will come back to in future blog entries, discussing some specific claims that are made. For this first post on the topic, I am going to briefly outline the core concept and explain why it is flawed relative to what we know about the Earth, space, physics, and just plain ol’ common sense. The main premise of the “Flat Earth” idea is that Earth is, well, flat. People who believe this idea believe that our planet is a a few miles thick, and everything that is on it – continents, oceans, and ice caps – rest on this flat object (“flat” being a relatively thin object considering how large in diameter it would be). In terms of basic geography, the North Pole is at the center of this disk, and Antarctica is actually a wall of ice that surrounds the outer rim, keeping the oceans from sloshing over. I kid you not. Earth is also the fixed center of the Universe, with everything “revolving around it in a plane level with the flat Earth.” Flat Earth believers (for brevity, I will call them “flaterthers,” a term that I just made up with the emphasis on the second syllable and the first “a” being pronounced like the “u” in “fluff”, fla-TER-thers) point to five main arguments for their beliefs: 1. Earth says still in space relative to … something. In the 1800s, physicists thought that there was a universal “thing” called the “ether,” through which light was supposed to travel. But an 1887 experiment now called the Michelson-Morley experiment disproved this concept by showing there was no preferred direction (even though they were trying to prove it) in perhaps the most famous “null result” in physics history. However, the flaterther argument somehow uses this to say Earth does NOT move, there actually IS an ether, and somehow this supports their idea … though I honestly don’t understand how. 2. The second argument that is made is that Earth can’t possibly orbit the Sun because (a) there’s no way for it to maintain its velocity over billions of years given that it’s traveling through an ether and therefore feels resistance, and (b) because when you orbit an object, there’s an acceleration, and any object “ahead” of the acceleration would get squashed and an object “behind” the acceleration would float away. 3. Objects on a curved surface would fall off. They’d slide “down” and when they reached the bottom, they’d fall off. Hence, according to flaterthers, it’s not possible for people in the USA to be standing up and people in Australia to be upside down, relative to those in the USA … Australians would fall off. 4. On a curved surface, there’s an inconsistent “down” direction, so if someone from the USA were to fly to Australia, they’d now be upside down! (I’m not sure why this is a separate argument from #3, but they consider it one on their website). 5. The only way to keep an ocean on the Earth is to keep it in the large bowl that is bound by the great sheets of ice that we normally think of as Antarctica. And, the only way to keep the air on Earth is to protect it with a large dome. Since I honestly don’t understand how #1 is used to justify the Earth being flat (they seem to equate that with Earth being the unmoving center of the Universe), I am not going to address it. In other words, this is the “Non-Sequitur” logical fallacy – the argument that Earth may be stationary relative to some permeating substance doesn’t say anything about Earth being flat. #2 is a little difficult to address because it requires some basic physics concepts and math in order to understand. First off, there are a few things they say that just aren’t true. For example, they state that Earth orbits “the sun at a radius of around five-hundred million kilometers.” This is not true. Earth’s average distance from the Sun is 149,600,000 km, or about 93 million miles. At the risk of sounding flippant … every school child knows this. In addition, they say that “Earth is supposed to be a large, spherical shaped ball of rock flying through space at hundreds of thousands of miles per hour …” Again, this is over-stated to make it sound impossibly big. Earth’s average orbital velocity is 29.78 km/s, which is 107,200 km/hr, or about 66,470 mph. Still pretty fast compared with our every-day lives, but not as big as they make it seem. Their actual arguments (as opposed to bad math/numbers) are a little more difficult to address with this claim. First off, no one has actually said Earth has maintained the exact same orbit and the exact same speed for billions of years – that is a Straw Man logical fallacy. And Earth does travel through a medium – not the ether, but rather the solar wind. The solar wind is made up of charged particles that are emitted from the Sun and stream outwards in all directions. In addition, Earth sometimes encounters asteroids that hit it. Every time something hits Earth, whether it be a giant asteroid or an elementary particle, the momentum from that object is added to Earth’s, and this can act to slow it down or speed it up. Because asteroids are so much more massive than the solar wind, I’ll address the impact of asteroids: Earth weighs 5.97*10^24 kg. That’s a lot. Let’s look at a dinosaur-killing, mass-extinction-causing asteroid impact – an asteroid that’s, say, 15 km in diameter – or around half the size of Manhattan. The average velocity of an Earth-crossing asteroid is around 15-20 km/sec, and most asteroids are made of rock, with a density of 3-4 gm/cm^3. That’s a total mass of 5*10^6 kg, or a difference of 18 orders of magnitude. That’s about the difference between the mass of our entire galaxy vs. the mass of the planet Mars. In other words, a dinosaur-killing asteroid event hitting Earth is like you, a person, running into a piece of dust. Even if that dust is going faster than a speeding bullet, you are not going to feel it. Similarly, even if Earth gets whacked by these things once every million years, it’s still not going to feel it. So, unless they are claiming that the ether is more massive than these asteroids, this claim doesn’t hold water (so to speak). As for the acceleration argument, this is just pretty much wrong. Our reference frame – the reference frame of EVERYTHING on Earth – is Earth. We move relative to our planet, our point of view is relative to our planet, and our velocity is relative to our planet. Yes, Earth goes in a really big circle around the Sun, and so there is a very very very slight accelerating “force outward” away from the Sun, but it is so small that there is no way you can feel it, and you folks who go to Weight Watchers don’t need to try to plan to go and weigh yourself at midnight instead of noon to get a lighter weigh-in. Argument #3 and 4 I’m going to lump together into the basic concept of a misunderstanding of gravity. As I said in the paragraph above, Earth is our reference frame for everything in our daily lives, and that’s because it is so big and we are so close to it (relative to everything else) that we are completely dominated by its gravity. In their third point, they argue that people would simply fall off of a round Earth once they get to the edge that “goes down.” Their analogy is a beach ball, where if you simply pour sand on the top of a beach ball, it will follow the curve of the ball until it gets to the side and then just fall off. The reason why this analogy doesn’t work is that the beach ball has effectively no gravity when compared with Earth. Things “fall down” because gravity pulls it “down.” “Down” is always towards the center of Earth (until you get beyond Earth’s gravitational pull). Now, if the beach ball were out in empty space and it was the most massive object around, a grain of sand that was placed on it wouldn’t move … it wouldn’t “fall” anywhere because “down” would be towards the center of the beach ball, regardless of whether the sand was placed next to the part where you blow into the beach ball or placed on the opposite side. This is why when an American goes to Australia, the American is not standing on their head when they get there. Throughout the flight (or boat ride) over, “down” is constantly changing so that it always points towards the center of Earth. In other words, yes, the plane effectively does turn upside down during the flight. It just does it very very slowly and you don’t notice it because it’s just following the curve of the planet, with the bottom of the plane always facing the surface of Earth. (And as a side note, if you go to Australia, stay longer in that country than it took you to fly there, speaking from personal experience.) As for argument #5, I really just have to resort to the ad hominem response: This is absurd. The belief that Earth is covered by a dome to keep the air in and that the edge is a giant sheet of ice to keep the ocean in is a juvenile concept that requires massive conspiratorial claims to maintain (which they do) since it negates space telescopes, the Apollo lunar missions, and expeditions to Antarctica, among other things. In addition, it flies in the face of simplicity, plausibility, and most people who are older than 5. That’ll wrap up this post on introducing the Flat Earth concept (and flaterthers). In future posts, I will address more specific problems with it, such as their explanation for seasons, sunsets, tides, their concept of gravity, and other tidbits.

[chan] general
Nov 17 00:33

stop... we all know the earth is a cube.... hmu on snap chat "thebeast710"

[chan] general
Nov 17 00:43


[chan] general
Nov 17 17:59

> People who believe this idea believe that our planet is a a few miles thick Bullshit. No legitimate flat earth researcher believes the earth is a "few miles thick." Many believe that the earth's thickness is at least as much as its breadth. Some believe it is a giant cube, set in a vast ocean, and that we are on the top side. Some believe it is an infinite plane that goes on in all directions, and that our earth is merely an isolated tiny section surrounded by the antarctic ice wall, with other earths and continents beyond that ice wall. Some believe the earth is actually four dimensional, so that no euclidean space exists beyond the boundaries of this universe which is speculated to be at least 25 thousand miles in all directions. > Earth is also the fixed center of the Universe, Bullshit. Polaris is the fixed center of the Universe, with earth below it and God's heavenly abodes above it. The heavenly bodies that we see above us, are a clock, or timepiece beneath the waters of the heavenlies. There are many theories about how to determine the center, but very few actual thinkers consider the earth to be the center of the Universe. > The solar wind is made up of charged particles that are emitted from the Sun and stream outwards in all directions. This theory is just that--a theory--and a bullshit conjecture at that. Critics of the flat earth idea generally actually know nothing about the flat earth idea, and while making asses out of themselves in their criticism, they think they are fronting great intelligence. There is far more visible, verifiable proof that earth is flat, than there is for a globe. The only proof you have for a globe is claims of the government and academia. If you trust their baseless and unprovable heresey, I suppose you consider that as "evidence."

[chan] general

Subject Last Count
fuck me I have 80 connections Dec 16 09:14 3
torIRC246 Dec 16 09:07 1
is there anyone here? Dec 16 08:45 3
suicide.note Dec 16 04:52 2
GBCREHX6 Dec 16 02:34 3
Grammar and Syntax Totalitarianism Dec 16 01:59 2
we hack the government Dec 15 22:51 3
bitcoin rising like crazy Dec 15 22:12 28
launch torIRC straight from a BM Dec 15 22:09 2
The Blue whale Game Dec 15 21:19 1
Camelot Dec 15 18:39 2
under control Dec 15 18:33 2
actually working mp4 file repair Dec 15 17:09 17
Geminid meteor shower peak Dec 13-14 Dec 15 15:39 18
cultists on the linux forums browbeat them into sticking to linux Dec 15 15:37 3
god fucking damn it fuck those cocksuckers at the FCC Dec 15 13:05 7
evolution - RNA world hypothesis Dec 15 13:03 7
windows93 Dec 15 10:01 1
check it out or die Dec 15 07:58 1
help Dec 15 03:58 2
Dear NASA phan boiz Dec 14 20:36 4
xxx Dec 14 19:20 1
please post your onion and uptime in UTC London time in this list Dec 14 16:43 6
RetroShare Dec 14 14:27 11
Hacking 101 Dec 14 08:21 2
Cat Goddess on the beach Dec 14 07:51 12
Profit Dec 14 07:45 1
Genghis Koyn warned about SEC clampdown months beforehand Dec 14 00:14 2
Nyx Dec 14 00:10 1
torIRC server Dec 13 23:53 16
mass extinction of BM users Dec 13 18:06 2
when you die Dec 13 15:56 1
Programming/hacking services provider Dec 13 13:23 1
OK lets start a chat Dec 13 07:19 15
Muhammad.. peace be upon him Dec 13 05:01 2
Bitmessage dead? Dec 13 03:22 7
why the fuck is nobody anything ? Dec 12 23:16 8
torIRC server online Dec 12 18:11 9
(no subject) Dec 12 17:09 10
Burkhard Heim Dec 12 15:14 2
CIA - Project STARGATE Dec 12 14:59 1
United States gravity control propulsion research Dec 12 14:15 1
torIRC Monday Dec 12 13:33 1
torIRC Monday Dec 12 13:29 23
new onion torirc Dec 12 05:23 1
torIRC mini ver. Dec 12 03:37 5
torIRC -- u gonna use it or not ? Dec 12 03:36 2
sent via API : torIRC9050.py Dec 12 03:29 15
The Revolution of Crypto-Anarchism is to design and spread rapidly a non-paradoxal cyberspace. Dec 11 15:59 2
torIRC9050.py Dec 11 15:14 4
torIRC Monday - code Dec 11 10:44 1
eerily quiet on bitmessage Dec 11 09:31 7
So much bullshit here! Dec 11 08:05 7
suicide Dec 11 03:16 8
Does this work Dec 11 02:15 2
Hello everyone! :) Dec 11 01:10 1
Is bittext.ch down? Dec 11 00:37 2
BitText importantY: important-info Dec 11 00:16 1
BitText mission007: The "general" chan's mission statement Dec 11 00:06 1
BitText LIST Dec 10 23:54 1
BitText ivr3ouAEyI: AfD_Mitgliederliste_16-05-01.csv Dec 10 21:02 2
BitText NYQIVP_0JH: AfD_WhatsApp_Name_bis-500 Dec 10 18:58 1
BitText 84p9HtVqo2: Afd-Mitglieder 2015 unvollstaendig csv Dec 10 18:44 1
torIRC Dec 10 18:05 5
((i)) UPDATE linksunten.indymedia.org files Dec 10 17:08 1
Hyphenated-American BM-2cXw4tSPxWu7q6ed51WoZgXXyJJ5kyB7Nx Dec 10 11:12 1
with style Dec 10 10:00 6
All I want for Christmas is White Genocide Dec 10 09:58 7
pedos Dec 10 09:34 3
Tor Browser 7.0.11 is released Dec 10 08:08 2
Greece citizens storm authorities buildings Dec 10 07:40 1
[chan] suicide-note Dec 10 06:50 2
[chan] suicide-note BM-2cVbzUVY4b21avMSbXMHmVR1pc6a5wEeTN Dec 10 06:42 3
[chan] suicide BM-2cTpc3iowqRLsz2CPf2eGZyUpZBDdhp1NB Dec 10 06:24 1
There is no place in modern Europe for ethnically pure states Dec 10 04:49 3
white countries for everyone (except whites) Dec 10 04:48 3
Harvard Magazine Promotes White Genocide Dec 10 02:30 2
White Australia must be Asianized Dec 10 02:18 1
Whites are a global minority Dec 10 02:18 2
strike fear in the heart of the white man Dec 10 02:09 1
hi there Dec 10 02:05 4
you can't breed out the africans Dec 10 02:04 1
We should commit mass suicide Dec 10 02:04 2
policies to enforce racial mixing of whites Dec 10 02:00 1
The extermination of white people is good news Dec 10 01:55 1
Race Traitor Magazine promotes white genocide Dec 10 01:50 1
anti-white 'supercultural' society Dec 10 01:45 1
We have got to eliminate the gringo Dec 10 01:41 1
Caucasians must be eliminated Dec 10 01:36 1
the challenge of racial interbreeding Dec 10 01:32 1
Everyone is our neighbour (except white people) Dec 10 01:26 1
To the flat earthers Dec 10 01:25 3
what if the NSA Dec 10 01:25 2
Eliminating Caucasians is a good thing Dec 10 01:21 1
not allowed to be white anymore Dec 10 01:16 1
White Europe will not survive Dec 10 01:11 1
bisexual anti-whites love fantasies of slaughtering white people Dec 10 01:07 1